I worked out a new voting system that, combining the good points of paper voting with those of computing, guarantees quick, honest and verifiable results. Please read details at www.ClearVoting.com

ACCESSIBILITYa

electronic voting and Democracy

Your Opinions

none previous chapter. Accesskey=1 none next chapter. Accesskey=2
logo of the site

electronic voting and Democracy

Your Opinions

 
send your opinions

 

2004-03-15   against e-vote   What about international control & certification of elections?

If electronic elections were held in a country like Saddam's IRAQ would it be possible for International Organizations (as UN, OCSE...) to check and certificate such electoral results?

I'm sure nobody could honestly certify such results.

So why should we presume that the above results could be certified if the electione were held in our countries? Because we are much more honest than any dictator around the world? Please let's be serius! In our countries somebody has certified ENRON's financial statements until the day of the final crash! Why should such people (and companies) become suddently honest when the matter of their job is giving the power to rule a country (and most of the whole world, in the case of USA) ?

I want to say that if we have a look at the problem of e-vote in its entirety we soon notice that it is not a technical problem, but a social one.

The risks are so huge and the forces in the battle so powerful that we, the people, should pretend to vote in the only safe way which is paper ballots! Of course with paper ballots some few votes may go lost, but not any foreign country, not any terroristic group, not any economical or political power will ever be able to alter results of our electons!

I think this is the real point and compared to it cryptography, VVPAT, codes, mathematical voting systems, and related things are all misleading technicalities!

Emanuele Lombardi


 
The site is made of several chapters. You can change chapter clicking on the arrows or pressing the access keys 1 and 2. Some chapters are made of several documents. You can change document clicking on the arrows or pressing the access keys 3 and 4. Access keys are described in the Accessibility page. Site Map is in this Site Map page.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. You are free to copy, distribute, display and perform the work and to make derivative works under the following conditions: 1) You must give credit to the original author (Emanuele Lombardi) and cite the url http://www.electronic-vote.org ; 2) you may not use this work for commercial purposes; 3) If you alter, transform, or build upon this work, you may distribute the resulting work only under a licence identical to this one.


This site uses valid XHTML 1.0!__ This site uses valid CSS__ Dublin Core Metadata Initiative__ Creative Commons License
This page complies with W3C WCAG P3 but accessibility is a very difficult matter: if you find the site not easily accessible, please let me know